Thursday, December 30, 2010

My Introduction

Note: This piece was originally published at the outset of this blog in June of 2010. I republish it with slight edits for new First Tier Toilet fans and for nostalgics.

I am starting this blog because I want to give underemployed college graduates the full picture regarding law school. The education industry continues to present manipulated data as fact to prospective students. The entertainment industry portrays the legal profession as a prestigious or glamorous profession.

I graduated with decent grades from a very highly-ranked "elite" [edit: T14] law school. I am good at networking. I have a strong resume, of which I am proud. In short, I "did everything right." This is not to say that I am entitled to anything but to show that there is more at issue than personal effort. There is a systemic problem in the legal education system. I am in a better situation both financially and job-wise than most of my friends [edit: not really anymore], so I cannot be accused here of doing this out of envy or bitterness. The vast majority of graduates from my school did not get serious job offers. Many of those who would otherwise be officially unemployed are working at the law library for $16 an hour or are working as temporary employees for a stipend and therefore show up as "employed." Most of the 2009 summer associates did not get offers, as far as I know; but even the few who did get offers are not as lucky as you would imagine. They will most likely leave the firms within six years, or they will be laid off. [Edit: No, they don't all "lateral" as partners in lower-ranked firms]. The lucky ones are the ones who got into the government. This, however, is not a back-up plan. Government agencies are now swamped with applications from Harvard and Yale students, with good reason. [Edit: The political situation has diminished the possibility of robust government hiring thanks to tax cuts and budget slashing pressures].

The problems facing the legal industry are not new, and you can find great summations of these problems at other blogs by young attorneys. We do have to consider outsourcing, digitization, and large corporations' recent reluctance to pay top-rate for work billed by associates. However, we also have to look at the reasons 0Ls have for choosing law school. They come out of college working dead-end jobs. They have no direction. They feel that they cannot move up in life without another degree. This is especially the case for liberal arts grads, but it also extends to those who majored in more useful fields. I will not say that life is great for college graduates. I know the employment figures. I know what the job situation is like. But believe me when I tell you that the situation for law graduates is even worse. Do not think that it will magically get better. All the problems that we are facing now originated during pre-crisis times. The crisis just accelerated the inevitable.

College graduates will continue to apply to law school in droves because they feel that their situation is hopeless otherwise. Surely, life could not be any worse with an additional degree. This is where they are wrong. A law degree can serve as an employment straitjacket. At worst, it is financial ruin. Law school is the easiest graduate professional program to get into, and it still does carry some "prestige" to laypeople. This prestige, sadly, does not buy you a sandwich.

8 comments:

  1. Someone should print this and hand it out at college graduations.

    ReplyDelete
  2. And, lest we forget, the significant toxicity of the JD in the non-law world.

    The JD is UNIQUE in its ability to affirmatively repel non-law potential employers, who will examine you youngsters incredulously when seeking that warehouse job post-TTT. While PhD's in Art History will get a pass when applying for that job at the Gap, the JD will be mercilessly pounded by the HR department as a suspect and hapless loser for not engaging in the "lucrative" practice of law.

    Beware the singular down-sides of the JD.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Your original post said that you were in a better both financially and job-wise compared to your peers, "but not really anymore." What does this mean? Did most of your peers find jobs and are now in a better financial position than you? Or did something happen to you that caused you to be more on par with your peers?

    I don't mean to be nosy, and certainly don't expect specifics, but if most of your peers found jobs since you started this blog, wouldn't that be a good thing and cause to share good news?

    ReplyDelete
  4. No, something happened to me to bring me down to a worse state. I'm still far from being in the worst of situations, but my situation has certainly deteriorated.

    None of my peers, as far as I know, is in a better position today. A few are in a far worse position.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I graduated in 2005 from a T-14 and was unemployed for almost a year. I was on a journal (not law review) and participated in moot court. My grades weren't fantastic, but they weren't bad. Fortunately, things turned around and I now have a fabulous job in big law. It took a long time to get here, and I certainly feel your pain, but unlike my friends who went to less prestigious schools, I have a shot at repaying my loans. Just thought I'd let you know that there were unemployed top tier grads before 2009, and at least some of us have managed to recover from a less than auspicious start.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Did you mean your law school was "highly ranked" among all law schools, or "highly ranked" among the T14? Really, in this economy, don't expect anything if you're outside of the T3. I'm in the top third at CCN and I have 0 prospects after graduation. Gonna go on to a PhD program I guess..

    ReplyDelete
  7. T14. What's your story? You can email me if you want,

    ReplyDelete